Not all “It” shoes are created equal. Just because a style is trending all over your feed—or spotted on a few celebrities—doesn’t mean it’s worth the investment. Some popular shoes look great online but disappoint in real life, whether due to comfort issues, styling limitations, or the simple fact that they’re already starting to feel outdated.
The good news? There are plenty of hyped shoes that do live up to the buzz. From cult-favorite sneakers that blend form and function to everyday staples that feel fresh in 2025, we’ve sorted through the noise to highlight the shoes that fashion insiders say are actually worth your time (and money).
Below, you’ll find 8 shoes that may not deserve their viral fame—and 8 others that truly deliver on the hype. If you’re planning to upgrade your footwear game this season, start here.
1. Balenciaga Triple S Sneakers

High-fashion lovers once adored the Balenciaga Triple S sneakers for their daring, oversized design. As fashion moves towards more streamlined silhouettes, these chunky shoes have started to feel outdated. The multi-layered sole, once innovative, is now seen by many as cumbersome, especially as minimalist sneakers gain traction.
While they still boast a loyal following, this sneaker’s appeal is waning among trendsetters. Whether you view them as a bold statement or a fading trend, there’s no denying their significant past impact on streetwear fashion.
2. The Row Dune Classic Sandals

Elegance meets simplicity with The Row Dune Classic Sandals, yet their $690 price tag raises eyebrows. Critics argue that despite their refined silhouette, the cost is hard to justify for what are essentially luxury flip-flops.
As debates continue, some fashionistas appreciate their understated charm, while others see them as an overpriced indulgence. The sandals embody a minimalist design ethos, perfect for beachside strolls or casual summer outings. Still, their value remains a point of contention among shoe enthusiasts.
3. Isabel Marant Bekett Wedge Sneakers

The fusion of a sneaker with a concealed wedge heel once made Isabel Marant’s Bekett Wedge Sneakers a must-have. However, as fashion trends evolve, the hidden heel has lost its allure. Today’s sneaker enthusiasts often prefer authenticity, favoring designs that don’t mask their true nature.
Though they offer a unique blend of casual and chic, these sneakers are now seen as a relic of past trends. Comfort and style are still prevalent, but the novelty of a hidden lift has worn thin.
4. Maison Margiela Tabi Boots

Once beloved by fashion insiders for their bold, split-toe design, Tabi boots are now facing backlash for being more polarizing than practical. While still an iconic piece, many fashion editors in 2025 are labeling them as overhyped—often hard to style, divisive in design, and less versatile than trendier minimal styles. As fashion leans toward wearable, clean lines, the Tabi boot’s shock factor is starting to feel a little… tired.
5. Nike Dunk Sneakers

Once a cornerstone of sneaker culture, Nike Dunk Sneakers have become a victim of their success. Their ubiquity has led to market saturation, causing a dip in their once-coveted exclusivity. Although still beloved by many for their diverse colorways and cultural significance, their overexposure has dulled their allure.
Enthusiasts now seek more unique designs outside this flood. Despite this, the Dunk remains an iconic piece in sneaker history, cherished by those who appreciate its origins and impact.
6. Golden Goose Superstar Sneakers

Known for their deliberately distressed look, Golden Goose Superstar Sneakers stir debate among fashion fans. While some argue the scuffed design offers a unique charm, others feel it undermines the value of a premium shoe.
Coupled with a high price point, these sneakers challenge the norms of polished fashion. Despite mixed opinions, they continue to appeal to those seeking individuality. Their ability to pair with casual and chic attire keeps them relevant, but their “worn” aesthetic remains contentious.
7. Adidas Yeezy Boost 350

The Yeezy Boost 350 once held the sneaker world in thrall, thanks to its revolutionary design and celebrity backing. Today, its appeal is challenged by market saturation and shifting tastes. As more consumers seek fresh styles, the Yeezy’s distinctive silhouette starts to feel less groundbreaking.
Despite this, its legacy in the sneaker realm is undeniable, known for merging streetwear with high fashion. While it may no longer dominate trends, its influence continues to inspire new innovations in footwear design.
8. Platform Flip-Flops by Various Designers

In a quest to elevate the humble flip-flop, designers introduced platform versions, but practicality often trumps style. Critics note they lack sophistication and can be awkward to walk in. Despite their attempt at fashion-forward innovation, many find them impractical for daily wear.
These flip-flops do offer a playful twist on a classic, appealing to those who love bold statements. However, their limited functionality and divisive aesthetics make them a polarizing choice in the world of casual footwear.
9. Adidas Samba

Celebrated for their timeless design, Adidas Sambas are experiencing a well-deserved resurgence. This classic sneaker, with its clean lines and versatile appeal, is capturing the hearts of a new generation.
Spotted on style icons like Kendall Jenner and Kaia Gerber, the Samba’s sleek aesthetic seamlessly transitions from casual to chic. Its enduring popularity lies in its ability to complement any outfit, proving that true style never goes out of fashion. As a staple in many wardrobes, the Samba remains a testament to enduring design and comfort.
10. New Balance 327

Merging retro flair with modern comfort, the New Balance 327 has caught the attention of fashion-forward individuals. Its unique silhouette features bold color blocking that stands out in any crowd. Praised for their affordability and style, these sneakers offer a nostalgic nod to past eras while fitting seamlessly into contemporary wardrobes.
The 327’s blend of aesthetics and comfort makes it a favorite among those who desire both flair and functionality. Whether for a casual day out or a sporty look, these sneakers deliver on all fronts.
11. Puma Speedcat OG

Inspired by motorsport, the Puma Speedcat OG emphasizes a sleek, streamlined design that’s making a stylish comeback. Its low profile and snug fit offer both aesthetic appeal and functionality, perfect for urban adventures.
Celebrities like Emily Ratajkowski have embraced their chic vibe, proving their relevance in today’s fashion scene. The Speedcat’s revival caters to those who appreciate subtle sophistication and sporty elegance. As trends lean towards slimmer silhouettes, these sneakers stand as a testament to classic innovation in footwear.
12. Nike P-6000

Blending nostalgia with modern flair, the Nike P-6000 draws inspiration from past running shoes, offering a sporty yet stylish option. Its layered design and comfortable fit resonate with sneaker enthusiasts looking for a touch of history.
As athleisure continues to dominate fashion, this sneaker delivers a perfect blend of past and present aesthetics. Ideal for both casual outings and active lifestyles, the P-6000 remains a versatile choice for those who appreciate a vintage nod within contemporary trends.
13. Salomon XT-Whisper

Combining outdoor practicality with a fashion-forward twist, the Salomon XT-Whisper stands out with its vibrant colorways and comfort-focused design. Loved by hikers and streetwear enthusiasts alike, it bridges the gap between function and style.
Whether trekking through rough terrain or navigating city streets, these sneakers offer durability without compromising on aesthetics. Their unique appeal lies in their ability to cater to diverse lifestyles, making them a favorite among those who value versatility and flair in their footwear choices.
14. Adidas Tokyo

The Adidas Tokyo’s retro gum sole and ultra-thin leather design have won over fans seeking sleek minimalism. This sneaker’s understated elegance makes it a versatile choice for any wardrobe, effortlessly transitioning from casual to refined settings.
Its popularity continues to grow among those who appreciate a classic yet modern aesthetic. The Tokyo pays homage to vintage styles while embodying contemporary sensibilities, serving as a timeless addition to any footwear collection.
15. Vivaia ‘Sneakerina’

Merging elegance and practicality, Vivaia’s ‘Sneakerina’ offers a sustainable and chic option for those who value both style and eco-friendliness. This ballet flat-sneaker hybrid is crafted from sustainable materials, providing comfort and sophistication.
Ideal for city dwellers who prioritize versatility, the Sneakerina effortlessly complements both casual and formal attire. Its unique design caters to those who seek individuality in a sustainable package, making it a thoughtful and stylish choice for modern wardrobes.
16. Miu Miu x New Balance Collaboration

When high-fashion meets athletic heritage, the result is the Miu Miu x New Balance collaboration. These sought-after sneakers merge Miu Miu’s luxurious aesthetic with New Balance’s sporty legacy, creating a footwear masterpiece.
Whether you’re hitting the gym or the runway, this collaboration ensures you’re stepping out in style. Its unique blend of comfort and elegance makes it a standout choice for fashion-forward individuals who refuse to compromise on either aspect. The collaboration exemplifies innovation and a seamless blend of two iconic brands.