Summer style changes after 40—and honestly, it gets better. You’re no longer chasing every trend or sacrificing comfort for a barely-there sandal. Instead, it’s about balance: finding shoes that feel breezy without feeling exposed, polished without trying too hard, and timeless without being boring. That’s where the right summer shoe comes in. The perfect pair should elevate your outfit, support your feet, and reflect the confident, refined version of you that exists now—not the version that used to squeeze into flimsy flip-flops or sky-high cork wedges.
In this guide, we’re spotlighting 5 summer shoes that keep it classy over 40—styles that work with your wardrobe and your life. And yes, we’re also breaking up with 4 that feel just a little too bare, both physically and stylistically. Let’s make space in your closet (and suitcase) for summer footwear that’s just as smart as it is stylish.
1. Leather Slide Sandals (With Structure)
Elegance meets practicality with leather slide sandals that offer structure and support. These sandals are designed with a molded footbed, providing comfort without sacrificing style. Perfect for pairing with linen trousers or a chic shirtdress, they offer a polished look for various occasions. Whether attending a garden party or a casual brunch, these sandals fit effortlessly into any summer wardrobe.
Their sleek design ensures they remain a timeless addition to your collection. Try ATP Atelier Rosa Sandals or Everlane Day Crossover Sandals to find your perfect match. These slides offer a balance of luxury and functionality, making them a wise investment for those who value both aesthetics and comfort in their footwear choices.
2. Espadrille Wedges with a Closed or Peep Toe
Espadrille wedges are a summer staple that combines style with practicality. These shoes offer a comfortable wedge that provides lift without compromising stability. The refined canvas or leather materials add a touch of luxury, making them suitable for a variety of occasions.
Whether you’re traveling or spending a day exploring a city, these wedges provide the perfect blend of comfort and style. They are particularly beneficial for those with swollen feet, as they offer ease and adaptability. Consider options like Castaner Carina or Vionic Maris to experience their versatile charm. Espadrille wedges are a must-have for those seeking elegance and functionality in their summer footwear.
3. Block-Heel Sandals with Wide Straps
Block-heel sandals with wide straps bring a touch of sophistication to any summer ensemble. These sandals offer a sturdy heel that adds refinement and grace, making them ideal for evening events or weddings. The wide straps ensure comfort and a flattering fit, providing both elegance and practicality. Pair them with flowing dresses or tailored outfits to complete your summer look.
Brands like Naturalizer Taimi or M.Gemi The Esatto Sandal provide excellent options for those looking to elevate their style. These sandals are perfect for workwear or special occasions, offering a chic yet comfortable choice for women over 40 who appreciate fashion and comfort in equal measure.
4. Low-Profile Leather Fisherman Sandals
An essential addition to any summer wardrobe. These sandals offer covered comfort with breathable design, ideal for city walks or vacation exploring. Their timeless appeal ensures they complement both casual and dressy outfits. Whether you’re heading to a casual dinner or taking a leisurely stroll, these sandals provide the perfect balance of style and practicality.
Explore options like Sézane Coline Sandals or Nisolo Huarache Sandal for a mix of tradition and trend. Fisherman sandals are a versatile choice for those seeking a blend of old-world charm and contemporary flair in their footwear.
5. Minimalist Toe-Loop Flats
Minimalist toe-loop flats offer a chic look without unnecessary embellishments, making them a sophisticated choice for the summer. Featuring a single toe loop and sleek leather band, these flats exude elegance and simplicity. They are best paired with lightweight summer attire, offering a refined yet relaxed appearance. Avoid options with excess rhinestones or synthetic materials to maintain their understated charm.
Brands like Jenni Kayne Crossover Sandals or Aeyde Thora Sandals provide quality choices that highlight their minimalist appeal. For those seeking a subtle yet stylish footwear option, toe-loop flats offer an ideal balance of comfort and class, perfect for various summer occasions.
6. Thin Flip-Flops (Even the Fancy Kind)
Thin flip-flops, even the fancy ones, often lack the support and structure needed for a sophisticated look. While they may seem convenient, these sandals can visually flatten the foot and offer little in terms of comfort. Best reserved for poolside relaxation, they may not be the most flattering choice for those seeking elegance.
Despite their popularity, they fall short in providing the necessary comfort and style for extended wear. Consider alternatives that offer both support and fashion, leaving thin flip-flops for casual, short-term use only. For women over 40, these sandals might not meet the expectations of a stylish summer wardrobe.
7. Gladiator Sandals That Lace Up to the Calf
Do we even need to explain why these don’t work after 40? Gladiator sandals that lace up to the calf can often feel more like a costume than a classy footwear choice. Their intricate design can visually shorten the leg, detracting from a streamlined look.
Often difficult to pair with refined summer outfits, they may not suit the elegant style many women over 40 seek. Their dated appearance and complex lacing can be more of a hassle than a fashion statement. Consider simpler, more elegant options for a polished summer look. If you desire a touch of gladiator style, opt for versions with shorter laces or ankle straps, avoiding the cumbersome full-calf designs.
8. Ultra-Strappy Flat Sandals
Ultra-strappy flat sandals might seem trendy, but they often come with drawbacks that outweigh their appeal. The abundance of straps can lead to discomfort, especially for aging feet that prefer less exposure. These sandals may lack substance, leaving them as an unwise choice for those seeking a blend of comfort and style.
Opt for a more structured slide or ankle strap design to maintain elegance without sacrificing comfort. The ultra-strappy look can be visually overwhelming, detracting from a cohesive outfit. For a refined summer choice, consider alternatives that offer support and chic simplicity, steering clear of this overly complex style.
9. Barely-There Transparent PVC Heels
Transparent PVC heels, though trendy, often present challenges that diminish their allure. These heels can fog up in heat, causing discomfort and blisters. They scream “trend piece” rather than timeless elegance, making them unsuitable for those prioritizing lasting style.
For women over 40, who value a blend of comfort and sophistication, these heels may not align with their fashion goals. Opt for footwear that offers breathability and classic appeal, ensuring a comfortable and stylish summer experience. Transparent PVC might catch the eye, but for enduring charm, look toward designs that offer more than fleeting trends.