Some shoes spark joy — others spark group chats, memes, and fashion debates that never die. In the age of screenshots and snarky TikTok reviews, no pair is safe from internet judgment. From iconic fails to forever favorites, the online fashion crowd knows how to crown a hero and roast a villain — especially when it comes to what’s on your feet.
But here’s the twist: sometimes the most dragged shoes started as trends, and sometimes the most loved ones took years to earn their cult status. Whether it’s because of design, comfort, nostalgia, or sheer meme-worthiness, certain shoes have found themselves either endlessly adored or brutally mocked.
We’re breaking it down once and for all — the shoes that the internet just can’t stop loving, and the ones it just won’t forgive. Here are the 10 most universally beloved shoes — and the 10 most relentlessly dragged, with zero mercy and plenty of commentary.
1. Crocs (Classic Clog)
Frequently seen as the footwear equivalent of a dad joke, Crocs’ classic clogs have become a symbol of irony in fashion. While their practical design made them a staple for comfort-seekers, their appearance has often been the butt of jokes.
Despite this, they’ve managed to stage a comeback, embraced by celebrities and fashion rebels alike. Their quirky charm lies in their unapologetic clunkiness, which has spawned countless memes across social media.
Interestingly, their resurgence in popularity has sparked debates about fashion’s cyclical nature and the thin line between ugly and trendy. Love them or hate them, Crocs have marched their way into internet infamy.
2. Five-Finger Toe Shoes
Often mistaken for amphibious footwear, five-finger toe shoes have had their fair share of online critics. Their distinctive toe-separated design, while functional for many outdoor enthusiasts, has been regularly mocked for its unconventional look.
Functionality aside, these shoes have struggled to shed their quirky image, with detractors comparing them to everything from frog feet to alien appendages.
Yet, the dedicated fanbase appreciates their anatomical benefits, proving that style sometimes bows to substance. As the internet continues its playful banter, these shoes stand as a testament to niche fashion’s enduring spirit.
3. Sketchers Shape-Ups
Promising to revolutionize walking workouts, Sketchers Shape-Ups introduced a curved sole meant to tone the body. Despite these claims, their bulk made them a target for fashion roasts, often labeled as “mall-walker chic.”
Consumers quickly turned them into a meme, their exaggerated appearance overshadowing their intended fitness benefits.
Nonetheless, Shape-Ups have managed to carve out a niche among those seeking comfort and utility over fashion. They serve as a humorous reminder of the gap between marketing promises and reality, all in a clunky, rounded package.
4. Platform Flip-Flops
Resurfacing from the depths of Y2K fashion, platform flip-flops have become iconic for their impracticality. Their exaggerated height and awkward design have made them a staple in ironic fashion circles.
Critics point out their lack of practicality, often comparing them to walking on stilts. Despite this, they have a dedicated following, celebrating the playful aesthetic they bring to the table.
Their resurgence highlights fashion’s cyclical nature and the love-hate relationship with trends that refuse to die. Platform flip-flops are a nostalgic throwback that continues to spark debates on style versus functionality.
5. Heelys
Beloved by kids and a nightmare for school officials, Heelys introduced a wheel to the sole of a shoe, making gliding a reality. While undeniably fun, their lack of style made them unfashionable in the eyes of many.
The internet never forgets, and Heelys have become emblematic of youthful whims that prioritize fun over fashion. Nostalgia, however, keeps them in the public eye, as adults reminisce about childhood adventures.
Despite the criticism, Heelys are a reminder of carefree days when practicality was secondary to fun. They remain a pop culture relic, frequently spun into internet humor.
6. Uggs with Mini Skirts
The early 2000s saw the peculiar pairing of Ugg boots with mini skirts, a style choice that continues to bemuse fashion critics. This combination, often attributed to the “peak 2005 confusion,” became a hallmark of misguided early-millennium style.
Despite its questionable nature, the look has been immortalized on Pinterest boards, serving as a nostalgic reminder of youthful fashion experiments.
While Ugg boots have enjoyed renewed popularity, the mini skirt pairing remains a cautionary tale, illustrating how trends can often miss the mark. The internet, of course, has not let it fade into obscurity.
7. Velcro Dad Sandals (Overly Chunky Style)
Even luxury brands couldn’t save Velcro dad sandals from being labeled as overly chunky eyesores. Their orthopedic design, often exaggerated, has made them a favorite target for fashion purists.
The internet’s verdict is clear: these sandals, despite their comfort, embody a style that’s out of tune with contemporary fashion sensibilities. Yet, their comfort has won them a place among those who value practicality.
They stand as a testament to the clash between high fashion and everyday comfort, proving that sometimes, fashion just wants to have fun. The sandals continue to feature in memes and style critiques alike.
8. Knee-High Converse
Combining the classic Converse silhouette with knee-high ambition was a bold move that didn’t quite win over the masses. Frequently spotted at festivals, these extended sneakers have been accused of trying too hard.
Critics argue their elaborate design borders on costume territory, making them a staple in worst-dressed lists. Nonetheless, they hold a niche appeal for those daring enough to sport them.
These shoes are a testament to the idea that fashion is subjective, with beauty lying in the eye of the beholder. The internet’s mixed feelings only add to their enigmatic allure.
9. Gladiator Sandals (That Go Up to the Knee)
Often described as more “Roman cosplay” than footwear, knee-high gladiator sandals have drawn criticism for their complex design. The elaborate lace-up look, while striking, often gets labeled as overwhelming.
In the realm of online fashion critiques, these sandals are often cited as an example of style over practicality. Yet, their bold presence on the runway displays the daring spirit of avant-garde fashion.
They draw upon historical influences, blending ancient aesthetics with modern flair. Love them or loathe them, gladiator sandals demand attention, sparking vibrant discussions in fashion communities.
10. Wedge Sneakers
The brainchild of designer Isabel Marant, wedge sneakers attempted to blend athletic wear with high fashion. Despite their initial hype, they quickly became a cautionary tale of hybrid fashion gone wrong.
Online critics pointed out their awkward design, which seemed neither here nor there. Yet, among certain fashion circles, they managed to capture a loyal fanbase appreciative of their unique aesthetic.
These sneakers represent a bold fusion of sport and glam, challenging traditional fashion norms. While not universally loved, they continue to intrigue and inspire discussion on fashion innovation.
11. Classic White Sneakers (Adidas Stan Smith, Veja, Air Force 1)
Universally admired, classic white sneakers like the Adidas Stan Smith, Veja, and Nike Air Force 1 have transcended trends. Their clean, simple design makes them a staple in wardrobes worldwide.
These sneakers seamlessly blend into any outfit, offering a perfect balance between comfort and style. From casual outings to more polished events, their versatility knows no bounds.
Their enduring popularity speaks volumes about their timeless appeal, bridging generational gaps and fashion divides. These shoes are a testament to the power of simplicity and elegance in footwear.
12. Chanel Two-Tone Slingbacks
Synonymous with style and elegance, Chanel’s two-tone slingbacks have earned their place as icons in the fashion world. Their sophisticated design, characterized by a neutral palette, makes them a favorite among fashion editors.
These shoes effortlessly enhance any outfit, adding a touch of class to both casual and formal ensembles. Their timeless appeal ensures they remain relevant across different fashion eras.
Admired for their understated elegance, the slingbacks embody the essence of Chanel: classic, chic, and eternally stylish. They continue to inspire admiration and aspiration among fashion aficionados.
13. Dr. Martens 1460 Boots
The Dr. Martens 1460 boots stand as symbols of rebellion, loved across various subcultures from punk to mainstream. Their rugged design and durable construction have made them a staple in fashion.
These boots effortlessly transition from edgy streetwear to more polished looks, showcasing their versatility. They’re a testament to the enduring appeal of sturdy, well-made footwear.
Dr. Martens have been embraced by creatives, musicians, and trendsetters, proving that classic designs never go out of style. Their legacy continues to grow, celebrated by both old and new generations.
14. Manolo Blahnik Hangisi Heels
Immortalized by pop culture, particularly by Carrie Bradshaw, Manolo Blahnik’s Hangisi heels are the epitome of luxury. Their jeweled buckle and elegant silhouette make them highly coveted.
These heels are more than just shoes; they’re a statement of sophistication and taste. Their timeless design ensures they remain a beloved choice for special occasions and red carpets.
The Hangisi heels symbolize the aspirational nature of fashion, where fantasy meets reality in a perfect blend. They continue to be a dream purchase for many, admired for their unparalleled elegance.
15. Nike Air Jordan 1
A cornerstone of sneaker culture, the Nike Air Jordan 1 holds a revered place in history. Beloved by sneakerheads, athletes, and fashionistas alike, they’re more than just shoes; they’re a cultural phenomenon.
These sneakers not only revolutionized basketball footwear but also influenced street style, becoming a symbol of cool. Their diverse colorways and designs offer something for everyone.
The Air Jordan 1’s enduring popularity highlights the impact of iconic design in shaping global fashion trends. They’re celebrated not just for their aesthetics, but for their role in sneaker history.
16. Converse Chuck Taylor All Stars
Converse Chuck Taylor All Stars are the sneakers that have truly stood the test of time. Their adaptable design allows them to fit into any wardrobe, appealing to a wide demographic.
From musicians to artists, these sneakers have been embraced by countless subcultures, symbolizing creativity and individuality. They’re a canvas for self-expression, with fans personalizing them to suit their style.
These shoes remain a beloved choice for their simplicity and ease, proving that sometimes, the classics are unbeatable. They’re a testament to the power of enduring design and universal appeal.
17. Gucci Horsebit Loafers
Renowned for their elegance and versatility, Gucci Horsebit loafers are a staple in sophisticated footwear. Their iconic design seamlessly transitions from office environments to casual settings.
These loafers are loved for their genderless appeal and classic aesthetic, making them a favorite among fashion enthusiasts. They embody a sense of timeless chic that few other shoes can match.
With their luxurious craftsmanship and understated elegance, Gucci Horsebit loafers are a testament to the art of fine shoemaking. They continue to be celebrated as symbols of style and refinement.
18. Birkenstock Arizonas
Once mocked for their orthopedic look, Birkenstock Arizonas have become a staple in modern minimalism. Their comfortable design and earthy aesthetic have won over fashion lovers worldwide.
These sandals offer a unique blend of functionality and style, proving that comfort doesn’t have to come at the expense of fashion. They’ve found a place in the wardrobes of those who appreciate understated elegance.
Birkenstock Arizonas highlight the shift towards more sustainable, practical fashion choices. They’re celebrated for their quality craftsmanship and timeless appeal, showing that true style is effortless.
19. New Balance 990 Series
The New Balance 990 series has transitioned from “dad shoes” to fashion-forward must-haves, embraced by models and fashion editors alike. Their emphasis on comfort and quality has made them a favorite.
These sneakers embody the essence of normcore style, merging practicality with a subtle sense of fashion. They’re loved for their understated design and versatile appeal.
New Balance 990s continue to be celebrated for their reliability and timeless charm. Their journey from niche to mainstream highlights the evolving nature of footwear trends and the embrace of comfort.
20. Black Strappy Mid-Heel Sandals
Simplicity meets sophistication in black strappy mid-heel sandals, a footwear choice that complements any outfit. Their sleek design makes them a go-to for both formal events and casual outings.
These sandals offer a blend of comfort and style, providing a flattering silhouette that suits a variety of looks. They’re beloved for their versatility and timeless appeal.
The enduring popularity of these sandals speaks to their ability to enhance any ensemble with grace. They remain a favorite for those seeking chic simplicity and understated elegance in their footwear choices.