Most Comfortable Steel Toe Shoes 2019 – Buyer’s Guide and In-Depth Reviews
When it comes to investing in a good steel toe footwear, comfort should always be one of your major considerations. Note that since you will most likely wear the protective steel toe shoes in the workplace, it is crucial to make sure that they are also as comfortable as possible.
The shoe needs to be really comfortable so you won’t end up complaining about pain and discomfort during the duration of your work. Fortunately, it is not that hard to find the most comfortable steel toe shoes today as most modern shoes under this category are mainly designed with the comfort of the wearers and users in mind.
Know the importance of finding a comfortable steel toe shoe as such can prevent you from hurting your feet and cramping your toes, especially if you decide to wear it in your workplace. By prioritizing comfort, you will be able to enjoy all the benefits that the steel toe shoe can offer without the risk of raising any complaints.
What are Steel Toe Shoes?
Steel toe shoes are safety shoes which act as additional protection for your feet. The right pair of safety shoes are designed and created to protect your feet from falling objects which may be heavy or pointed, and can even protect from extra cold or extra hot conditions which may ordinarily damage the feet. They usually also contain a midsole plate which shields the under sole from punctures that can occur from below the shoe. The steel toe plates prevent damage to the toes themselves as well as the top area of the foot.
The international standard for steel toe shoes is that the toe protection area must be able to withstand a minimum of 200 joules of impact and must carry at least 1000kg of resting mass. Steel toe shoes are the heaviest and most dense of all safety shoes and because of this, they are usually the first choice for protective toe caps. Steel toe shoes tend to be not at all susceptible to damage and can even bend without breaking.
Most Comfortable Steel Toe Shoes List
1. Timberland PRO Powertrain Sport – Best of the Best
2. KEEN Utility Atlanta Cool – Best Bang for the Buck
3. Skechers for Work Holdredge – Hot New Product
4. Timberland PRO 40008 Mudsill – Editor’s Choice
6. Skechers for Work Synergy Ekron – Hot New Product
9. Caterpillar Brode – Editor’s Choice
Benefits of the Most Comfortable Steel Toe Shoes
There are so many good things that you can get from investing in comfortable steel toe shoes and wearing them all the time. For one, it is highly protective, making it a great footwear for any workplace, especially those that expose you to plenty of hazards and harm.
The steel toe footwear can resist scrapes and tears, giving you the protection you need in case you get accidentally exposed to some hazardous substances. Most steel toe shoes also come with a sole with an impressive traction. Such traction can help you stay grounded even if you are on a slippery surface.
The fact that most steel toe shoes come with full lining also make them quite comfortable. In addition, the safety shoe features a protective strengthening support, offering protection to your feet from injury. Expect the shoe to be really useful especially if you are in the construction industry as your tasks often require handling heavy machines.
It also offers protection to flying objects, punctures, electrical things, and extreme weather. With all these benefits, it is safe to say that a steel toe shoe is one of the best footwear you can invest in. It is vital to your safety but you also need to ensure that you are getting the most comfortable one.
Here are 10 of the most comfortable and protective steel toe shoes that you should consider investing in if you want to feel safe at work without compromising your comfort.
Top 10 Most Comfortable Steel Toe Shoes For Men 2018
1. Timberland PRO Powertrain Sports Alloy-Toe EH Construction and Industrial Shoe – Best of the Best
A high level of comfort is what I can guarantee if you decide to purchase the Powertrain Sports Alloy-toe EH Construction and Industrial Shoe for men from the Timberland brand. It has a lightweight construction, which is one of the reasons why it is indeed remarkably comfortable.
Aside from focusing on being lightweight and comfortable, this shoe is also made in a way that it fits the different kinds of hazards usually present in a work environment. With that, expect to receive a work-ready protection. Excellent structural support is also one positive thing you can expect from this shoe.
Such support can be attributed to the inclusion of a fiberglass shank into its construction. It has a casual style, making it suit any work environment. I find the upper of this footwear impressive as it is constructed from premium-quality rip-stop nylon material. It has a built-in synthetic sole.
I also noticed how efficient the safety toe cap of this shoe is in giving excellent protection to wearers. In addition, there is a mesh lining inside. Everyone is aware of how comfy the mesh material is, especially when used as a lining for a shoe. The good thing about this lining is that it can regulate or control other through its antimicrobial treatment.
The unique, slip-resistant outsole is also a big advantage. Another edge of this shoe is that the outsole makes use of an anti-fatigue technology. That said, you gain some assurance that you won’t suffer from extreme foot fatigue when you decide to wear this footwear from Timberland.
All-day protection can also be expected from the electrical hazard protection given by this shoe. Another good thing about these comfortable steel toe shoes is the cement construction as it boosts its flexibility while also significantly reducing the break-in time. It does not come with a waterproofing feature, though, which is its drawback.
- Highly comfortable due to the fact that it’s lightweight and made of comfy materials
- Impressive structural support guaranteed to be provided by the fiberglass shank
- Attractive, casual style
- All-day protection as it has a safety toe cap and is slip-resistant
- Sports an electric-hazard protection
- Utilizes an anti-fatigue technology
- Not waterproof
If the highest level of comfort and protection is what you are after, then this specific Timberland product surely fits your needs.
2. KEEN Utility Atlanta Cool Steel Toe Work Shoe – Best Bang for the Buck
Made of leather and mesh, I can also say that the KEEN Utility Atlanta Cool Steel Toe Work Shoe for men works well for those who are really after comfort without having to sacrifice the level of protection and durability. This shoe from KEEN is known for its sturdiness and is one of the most comfortable steel toe shoes.
It is tough and sturdy in the sense that you can use even in various hazardous working conditions, like roofing, framing, and construction. Despite being made tough, it is still stylish. In fact, its style is good enough that you can wear it confidently as your daily shoe.
I also think that the built-in right and left asymmetrical steel toe cap performs excellently in protecting users as it aids in preventing possible injuries due to impact and compression. It also has a high EH-protection rating. One thing I admire about this shoe is that it also has an additional sturdy toe cap made of rubber.
Such offers extra protection for sensitive areas. It has a rubber outsole, which can help anyone avoid slipping due to its slip and oil-resistant and non-marking nature. Expect it to help maintain the dryness of your feet because it uses Nubuck leather known for its water-resistant nature.
In terms of comfort, this work shoe from KEEN will never disappoint. One thing that makes it comfortable is its lightweight construction. It is also flexible that you can use it no matter how active your tasks are.
There is a hydrophobic mesh liner integrated to it, too, which serves as a thermostat, ensuring that your feet stay cool when dealing with an extremely warm temperature while also helping you to stay warm during the cold weather.
It has a low-cut design, though, so your socks are prone to getting wet, especially if you don’t wear pants. It also has a minimal arch support but rest assured that it is fixable by using an additional insole or insert.
- Offers a high level of durability
- Stylish enough to be worn as a daily shoe
- Highly protective – thanks to its steel toe cap and its slip and oil-resistant nature
- Boasts of a lightweight construction while also being flexible
- Made of comfortable materials, like leather and mesh
- Socks might get weight if you don’t wear pants because of its low-cut style
- Only has a minimal arch support
Still, this is a flexible, tough, protective and comfortable footwear from KEEN, which works well for you, especially if your job requires you to move constantly and quickly.
3. Skechers for Work Holdredge Steel Toe Work Shoe – Hot New Product
Your desire to own a comfortable steel toe work shoe might also be fulfilled by investing in the Skechers for Work Holdredge Work Shoe for men. One thing I immediately noticed and liked in this footwear is its rugged and sporty style. Combine that with the high level of comfort it provides and you have a top-quality shoe.
The upper of this footwear is constructed from synthetic, mesh fabric, and leather materials. It has a lace-up design. One reason behind its ability to make wearers comfortable is the insole cushioned with memory foam. Due to the memory foam, expect your feet to be well-cushioned while following your feet’s natural contours.
Just like any other footwear with a steel toe cap, this one from Skechers also sports a remarkable level of protection. One protective feature it has is its electrical-hazard safe design. There is also an oil-resistant and non-slip outsole. The sole is also highly versatile while being safe to use on oily and wet surfaces.
I love the overall construction on this Skechers shoe. It boasts of highly durable synthetic overlays found on the sides, heel, and toe. In addition, I enjoy the cooling effect of the shoe, which can be attributed to the mesh fabric panels present on the footwear’s sides, collar, and toe.
You can also find stitching accents on the shoe as well as a layered side on the overlays, increasing the shoe’s stability. There is also a padded tongue and collar, as well as a lining made of soft fabric, further increasing its level of comfort. The shock-absorbent midsole is also a big advantage.
As for the flaws, I could say that it would be on the sizing. It’s a bit bigger and wider than what your original size might be so it is advisable to really pick the perfect size.
- Features a rugged and sporty style
- Upper made of comfortable materials, namely synthetic, mesh fabric, and leather
- Boasts of a nice lace-up design
- Offers remarkable protection – thanks to its non-slip, oil-resistant, and shock-absorbent nature
- Sports comfy features, including the padded collar and tongue, and soft fabric lining
- Sizing issue
This Skechers shoe is a good choice with the many remarkable and impressive features it has but make sure that you get the right size to make the most out of it.
4. Timberland PRO 40008 Mudsill Low Steel-Toe Lace-Up – Editor’s Choice
What is good about the Timberland PRO 40008 Mudsill Low Steel Toe Shoe for men is that it offers a great combination of comfort and safety. It is one of the most comfortable steel toe shoes you can find today while also being capable of offering some of the best features linked to a top-quality footwear.
One remarkable point I noticed in this Timberland shoe is that it has a rubber sole known for its heat, oil, abrasion, and slip-resistant nature. The rubber material used in it is also durable so I can say that it won’t fall apart that fast. It is a safe and protective shoe, too, as its steel toe cap helps prevent crushing or injuring your toes and feet.
It makes use of sturdy leather and mesh for its upper, which makes it as durable and comfortable as you want it to be. It has a midsole, which features a lightweight cushion courtesy of the molded EVA. The mesh lining also sports an antimicrobial treatment designed to offer comfort to your feet while also keeping odor under control.
It also boasts of its shock-diffusion feature as well as a comfort system, which works 24/7. The fact that it has a built-in leather and nylon ghillie lacing system also guarantees that it can offer a more secure fit. Impressive structural support is also provided by its nylon shank.
The laces used on top are not that durable, though.
- Offers an excellent combination of comfort and protection
- Rubber sole integrated into the shoe, which is also known for resisting slips, oils, abrasion, and heat
- Features a steel toe cap, preventing your feet from getting crushed or injured
- Comfy with the aid of the leather and mesh upper and the lightweight cushion used inside
- Shock-diffusion feature
- Not that durable laces on top
This lace-up steel toe shoe from Timberland is a nice investment as it is guaranteed to provide wearers with comfortable protection.
5. New Balance MID627 Steel Toe Work Shoe
Another shoe, which, I think, is worthwhile to include in the list of the most comfortable steel toe shoes, is the MID627 Steel Toe Work Shoe for men from New Balance. In my opinion, one of the most impressive qualities of this footwear is its durability. It has a durable construction so it is safe to say that it has the potential of lasting long.
It comes with a 10-mm drop as well as a 52 Durometer insert or midsole. I also noticed that the footbed is made of EVA foam, providing just the right amount of cushion for comfort. There is also a built-in gusseted tongue, which is helpful in ensuring that debris does not get in, thereby offering the ultimate protection for your mid-foot.
The injection-molded EVA foam used for the midsole is also known for its firmness while still providing a kind of cushion, which is flexible. The textile lining used in the footwear also provides the perfect environment for proper cushion. In addition, there is a padded collar, which also features a webbing heel pull tab.
Such tab makes it possible for you to easily and quickly put on and take off the shoe. While wearing the shoe, you also have an assurance that you can stay comfortable the whole day. There is an internal shank designed for stability as well as a safe and non-marking outsole, which is also recognized for being slip-resistant.
One problem with the shoe is that it is not that suitable for prolonged use in concrete. The sole is also prone to splits and tears, especially if exposed to extremely harsh weather conditions all the time. However, you can make it last longer by ensuring that you take good care of it.
- Lightweight, comfortable, and well-cushioned, so wearing it for long hours won’t be a problem
- Slip-resistant rubber outsole
- Easy and quick to put on and take off – thanks to the webbing heel pull tab
- Guaranteed stability considering the presence of an internal shank
- Prevents debris from penetrating
- Not ideal for prolonged use on concrete surfaces
- Sole is prone to splits and tears
Despite the issues, this New Balance shoe is still an impressive product as it is comfortable and light while also offering excellent protection to wearers.
6. Skechers for Work Synergy Ekron Alloy Toe Work Shoe – Hot New Product
You also have easy access to a comfortable and safe footwear with the availability of the Skechers for Work Synergy Ekron Alloy Toe Work Shoe. I specifically like the sporty and stylish look of this shoe. Combine that with the fact that it is highly comfortable and protective and you have a shoe that’s designed to offer utmost satisfaction.
As for the overall construction, expect this Skechers shoe to boast of an upper made of smooth and soft trubuck leather as well as synthetic material. It also sports a lace-up and sporty style. Such look is finished with attractive and durable overlay accents and stitching.
Skechers also brought comfort to an even higher level by ensuring that this product features a memory foam insole. I think that this insole is a big advantage, as far as comfort is concerned, because the memory foam contours and shapes your feet naturally. It is also designed in a way that users will enjoy a more relaxed fit.
In terms of protection, Skechers for Work Synergy Ekron Work Shoe will never disappoint. For one, it can resist slips, oils, and moisture, so you are somehow assured of your safety when you put it on and you deal with surfaces with lots of moisture. It also guarantees a high electric hazard protection rating.
The safety toe cap featured in this footwear is also enough to keep you away from possible foot pain, discomfort and injuries. Expect the toe area to be quite tight initially, though, which also means that it’s necessary to break it in first.
- Sporty and stylish lace-up design
- Smooth and soft trubuck leather used for the upper, thereby promoting comfort and durability
- Features attractive stitching and overlay accents
- Sports a memory foam insole, offering additional comfort
- Slip and electrical hazard resistant
- Break-in needed as the toe area is quite tight at first
Once you successfully break the shoe in, you’ll start to love all the positive qualities and features that it possesses.
7. Reebok Work Sublite Cushion Work Construction and Industrial Shoe
Reebok also proves that it is one of the best brands in the footwear industry with its Sublite Cushion Work Construction and Industrial Shoe. Made of mesh and coming with a synthetic sole, I can safely say that this shoe is both comfortable and sturdy. It is also protective due to its safety toe cap, which meets EH protection and safety standards.
This shoe promises to improve the mobility of its users – thanks to the built-in full-foot flex grooves. Such also flexes as you take each step, promoting mobility and comfort. I also enjoy watching the low-cut design of this footwear. Such is enough to provide it with an athletic and sleek look while also giving your ankle more mobility.
As for comfort, I can guarantee that this Reebok shoe won’t fail you. A high level of comfort is made possible with the memory tech massage footbed used in the shoe. Such footbed adapts to the shape and contours of your feet naturally. In addition, it offers instant cushioning, maintaining such comfort for long hours.
There is also a midsole made of Sublite foam and that is helpful in offering a soft support and lightweight cushion. Also, the safety toe cap used in the shoe does not add too much weight to it. Despite being lightweight, there is also an assurance that it can maintain a high level of impact protection.
The mesh used for the upper is also beneficial as it promotes breathability and cooling comfort the entire day. One problem I noticed, though, is that it is a bit narrow on the toe but it is something that you can fix by breaking it in. Also, it tends to squeak a bit once you take your step.
- Upper is made of mesh, making the shoe breathable while also promoting a cooling effect
- Mobility of users guaranteed – that’s made possible with the shoe’s full-foot flex groves
- Features a nice low-cut design
- Memory tech massage footbed, which adapts to the shape and contours of your feet
- Instant cushion provided
- Quite narrow on the toe
- Squeaks a bit
Yes, there are flaws in this Reebok shoe but I can still safely say that its pros far outweigh its cons, making it one of the best work footwear you can find on the market today.
8. Timberland PRO Mudsill Steel Toe Oxford Shoe
If you are a worker who needs to spend long hours in a risky and hazardous workplace, then you will surely fall in love with the comfort and protection that the PRO Mudsill Steel Toe Oxford Shoe for men from the Timberland brand can offer. It is mainly designed to protect workers from damages and injuries caused by demanding and tiring work schedules.
I immediately noticed that premium-quality leather used in the overall construction of this Timberland shoe. I like such material as it provides a hundred percent assurance regarding its toughness and sturdiness. It also has a solid and stable steel toe box. I think it is helpful in the protection and safety department.
One more remarkable thing I noticed in this footwear is the thick rubber sole. Such is known for offering more than enough grip when used on wet and oily surfaces. The sole is slip and oil-resistant while also being able to handle abrasion and impact that well. It also protects you from live current and shocks.
Another nice feature is the cross-section lining, which also has a bacterial treatment designed to control smell. I can also say that this shoe performs well when offering a lightweight padded support. Such is made possible by its EVA cushioned outer sole. It is comfortable to wear even on concrete.
Also, the leather material used is soft, thereby minimizing the time you need to spend to break it in completely. As for drawbacks, one thing I noticed is the limited options for colors. Some also complained about feeling slightly uncomfortable in case of heavy waterlogging.
- Ideal for use on risky and hazardous work environments because of its highly protective and secure features
- Premium-quality yet soft leather used, promoting comfort and minimal break-in period
- Sports a thick rubber sole that offers adequate grip
- Resists oil, slips, abrasion, and impact
- Offers protection from live current and shocks
- Limited color options
- Offers slight discomfort during heavy waterlogging
Still, most of the features integrated into this Timberland footwear can guarantee the safety, security, and comfort of wearers.
9. Caterpillar Brode Steel Toe Work Shoe – Editor’s Choice
The Caterpillar Brode Steel Toe Work Shoe is also one footwear primarily designed to protect wearers and make them comfortable in the workplace. It has a low-cut design but it performs well when used by workers, especially those with highly demanding jobs. Despite being a steel toe shoe, I can still say that it is incredibly lightweight.
It is made of genuine suede leather material. It also makes use of a nylon mesh lining, which further improves its quality. It is capable of absorbing shock waves and contractions in the workplace while also giving your feet the protection they need from electric hazards and shocks.
I like the soft and comfortable material used in the upper as it does not cause any discomfort and pain on my ankles and entire feet. I think that its breathability as well as the adequate support it provides also improve the ability of the footwear to offer comfort. It is a balanced footwear, making it suitable especially for those with flat feet.
The outsole is based on slip-resistant rubber, which also does a great job in enhancing traction. It has a cement construction, too, which offers additional support, durability, and flexibility. It has a downside, though, and that is the fact that it is inappropriate to use in wet conditions as it is not waterproof.
- Suitable for demanding work environments
- Genuine suede leather used in its construction, ensuring comfort and sturdiness
- Offers protection from electric hazards and shocks as well as shock waves and contractions
- Soft and comfortable upper
- Highly breathable
- Not waterproof
With its ability to provide comfort and protection, this Caterpillar shoe is definitely worth to buy.
10. Skechers for Work Hartan Steel Toe Slip-On Shoe
Skechers also did a good job when it created the Hartan Steel Toe Slip-on Shoe. As the name suggests, it is a slip-on footwear, which immediately ensures that it is comfortable since you can just conveniently and quickly slip it on and off. With this Skechers shoe, I can say that you can enjoy all-day comfort and protection.
One remarkable quality of this shoe is its comfortable and durable upper courtesy of the smooth yet sturdy leather used in it. It has a casual style while featuring a steel toe cap, which is known for being capable of giving the best protection to users. It also features nice stitching and attractive overlay accents.
Comfort is also guaranteed when you wear this footwear as it comes with an insole made of gel-infused memory foam. In addition, it is known for keeping wearers safe from electric hazards. The fact that it has a nitrile rubber lugged outsole is also an advantage as it lets you resist chemicals and oils.
It has a solid design and is really easy to slip on. Expect the fit around the ankle to be tight at first, though, but you can solve this problem by successfully breaking the shoe in.
- Offers all-day protection and comfort
- Soft yet tough leather used in constructing the shoe
- Nice stitches and attractive overlay accents integrated into the shoe
- Gel-infused memory foam used in the insole, promoting comfort
- Keeps you safe from oil, chemical and electric hazards
- Tight around the ankle at first
Once broken in, you will start to notice how comfortable and protective this shoe from Skechers actually is.
How to Find the Best Steel Toe Shoes?
If you are a worker who carries a physically demanding job, then you need to invest in a comfortable and lightweight shoe, which can also offer you the protection you deserve. One such shoe is that with a steel toe cap. However, with the many brands of steel toe shoes in the market today, you may be confused during the selection process.
In this specific section of this buying guide, you will get to know some vital factors to keep in mind and consider when searching for a high-quality, protective, and comfortable steel toe safety shoe. You will also gain some tips to ensure that what you are picking is really the perfect one for you.
1. Size and Fit
If you want your steel toe shoe to not let you down as far as comfort is concerned, then ensure that you are getting a perfect size and fit for it. The right size and fit of shoes matter a lot when it comes to giving you comfort. If you buy a shoe, which has a poor fit, then you will most likely find it difficult to get your job done.
The same is specifically true for a steel toe shoe as accuracy in fit and size contributes a lot to raising its comfort level. If possible, buy a shoe, which is one-half or one size bigger to be on the safe side. Your goal should be to pick a size that naturally fits the shape of your feet.
2. Comfort and Convenience
Comfort should always be prioritized when finding the best steel toe shoes for you. Note that you will be wearing it in the workplace for several hours each day. Prioritize comfort and safety. As mentioned earlier, the right fit and size are essential to help you stay comfortable.
Assess all the materials used in the shoe, too. The materials should all be comfortable so they do not end up weighing you down once you start working. Furthermore, remember that each material used in the shoe has a different level of comfort and breathability.
If possible, go for one with a full-grain leather or nylon mesh as such materials are known for their high comfort level. There should also be enough lining and cushion within the shoe. It should also come with an internal support mechanism and footbed design engineered to offer excellent arch support and balance.
You also have a hundred percent assurance that you will stay comfortable when you are wearing your steel toe shoe if it has ample width. There should be ample width inside in the sense that you can comfortably move your toes effortlessly.
With such adequate width, you know that you can prevent your toes from rubbing the footwear, thereby ensuring that you won’t end up getting hurt and feeling uncomfortable during the time you wear it.
You need a tough and durable shoe, which can handle all the challenges you put it to no matter what work environment you are in. The durability and sturdiness of your shoe contribute a lot to how long it will last. Durable shoes can also offer the best possible defense for your feet.
It is tough enough that surviving any unexpected hazards will be easier for it. Check the boot’s overall construction to know how sturdy and durable it is.
The level of protection offered – A steel toe shoe always offers a high level of protection. Aside from protecting you from several safety hazards in the workplace, it is also important for the shoe to be waterproof and usable in all types of weather. It should also be made in such a way that it lets you handle even the worst conditions at work.
These include wet gravel, snow, debris, and mud. It should also be non-slip plus should offer a high electric hazard rating. It should have a hundred percent non-conductive and non-metallic substances, like rubber and fiber, to prevent electricity from passing through them.
Some Additional Tips to Take Note Of
You also stand a chance of getting the best steel toe shoe, and the most comfortable one at that, if you keep in mind these helpful tips, especially once you start wearing it:
1. Wear a pair of socks suitable for steel toe
Once you have bought the right shoe for you, make sure that you wear it with the right socks – those suitable for steel toe footwear. The good news is that you can easily find high-quality socks for this shoe in the market. In most cases, they range from around $12-$18.
Most of these socks come with an additional padding, offering extra cushion that can provide you with the kind of comfort you need the entire day.
2. Buy good insoles
Invest in high-quality insoles, too. Just like the socks, the insoles can also be expected to offer additional cushion, so they are really useful when it comes to boosting comfort. One way to find the perfect insole is to ensure that it perfectly fits your shoe comfortably.
3. Break it in
Do it in a gradual manner, though. Note that most of those who complained about discomfort when wearing this type of shoe are actually those who wear unable to break it in. What you can do to break it in is to wear it for a few minutes only at first. Then increase the time you wear it while you get used to it.
Doing this makes it possible for you to break in the non-steel areas of your shoes a bit. It is also a big help in ensuring that your feet start to get more tolerant to the footwear. Ensure that it is fully broken in before you use it at work, especially if it involves long hours of staying on your feet.
The most comfortable steel toe shoes are among the best footwear that’s worthy of your investment. Keep in mind that as a worker, it is necessary to prioritize your comfort as such can also have a direct and positive impact on your health and productivity.
In addition, a good steel toe boot can also make you guarantee your safety with the plenty of protective features it has. With that, avoid skimping when it comes to the footwear. Take your time in selecting the best steel toe shoes that can offer ultimate protection with the aid of this buying guide.